NOTE
I will, in this blog, be dealing with raising children of all ages, from infancy to young adulthood.
I am not,however, going to do this in chronological order but rather address different stages as they come up for me. This way the blog can be appealing to a wider audience. Also some blogs, this one today for example, is relevant at all stages of development. I hope this works for you. Also please remember to register so you don't miss out on any posts. Just click the subscribe button at the bottom of the page.
BUILDING A RELATIONSHIP WITH YOUR CHILD
I have for a long time looked at building a relationship
with a child as the equivalent to weaving cloth and, as in weaving cloth, the end
result can be strong, flexible and well wearing over time or something loosely bound, weak and unable to with stand stress. You cannot un-weave the past. Your relationship with your child is
something you will live with for the whole of your life so weave carefully and take the time to make sure it is a relationship that can withstand time.
In terms of your child the threads of your cloth are created
by each and every interaction you have with your child. Not that all interactions are equal, some
will be more significant and others less so, resulting in thinner or thicker
threads. But what determines the strength of the thread is the quality of the
interaction. Positive interactions yield
strong threads and negative interactions yield weak threads. So the more positive your interactions are
with your child over time the stronger the weave of the cloth and the stronger
the relationship. Relationships are built by the everyday, little interactions that you have with your child. It is the sum of these that create the fabric of the relationship. You have to work at it all the time. No interaction is insignificant.
. This is why parenting requires so much of our attention,
particularly in the early
formative years. It is during this time that you are laying
the strands that will make up the foundation of your
relationship and the early yarn is defining the shape of your cloth.
The time will come, much sooner than you can possibly believe,
when the opportunities for adding to the cloth becomes far less frequent. Your child, when he starts school, will be looking beyond the family
orbit for his influences and will be guided much more by external factors, friends,
culture, school, etc. than by you and his family. Your interactions will still be very important but as he grows older and moves through the educational system your influence will diminish.
In later blogs I will be looking at how to influence your child even as he slips out of your orbit but for now I’d like to look at how you might best use
your skills to build a strong relationship with your child while the building
is good. The older he becomes the less time he will spend at home and the less
opportunity you will have to “weave” a relationship with him. So make each one
count by developing constructive principles that will almost reflexively
influence and shape you interactions. It is not practical to expect that every
time you speak to your child you analyze each interaction which is why you need
to consciously decide on the principles that you will use to guide you through all of your interactions. You need to, over time and very carefully, develop ways of responding to your child that are constructive and then make these reactions reflex reactions.
WHAT KIDS NEED AND WANT
In order to develop a relationship with your child you need to understand your child and what his needs are at each stage of development. The frustration here is that as soon as you master one stage he is on to the next. It feels like you're always starting over. One of the first things your child will need is to feel as though he counts and his opinion counts. From a very early age they want you to see them as person and one that is valued.
Too many parents take the attitude that I am the boss, you are
the child, you will do as I say, end of story. Sounds easy; too bad it doesn’t
work. You can’t raise a child the way you’d run a boot camp. In his very
insightful book choice theory William
Glasser labels this approach External Control Psychology. Using this approach
we control behavior through a system of rewards and punishments, not unlike
Pavlov’s dogs. This system works rather
effectively at molding behavior while children are young but that is all that
it does. This approach can be effective in the moment but it breaks down
because it does not generalize, as the behaviorists have shown. The child
responds as desired when he is in your company but since the behavior is
dependent on your presence it does not generalize to situations when you are
not there. What it fails to do is to
provide the kind of parent/child interactions that helps the child internalize
the principles of behavior that you want for your child. External Control does not build parent child
relationship based on mutual respect. If this approach is relied on too heavily
it will build resentment and hostility in the child as he begins to feel
coerced and controlled. The result is that you will have a child who resents
you and has no experience of confidence in his own decision making, and in the
end is both dependent on you and resentful of you at the same time.
The alternative is to
give your children choices and then teach them to make the right ones as you
build a positive and supportive relationship. As Glasser puts it “We must realize that if we coerce
anyone too long there will be a point of no return. We may never be close
again. Lacking this closeness, some
children begin to give up on relationships and, eventually, embark on a
lifelong destructive search for pleasure.
To achieve and maintain the relationship we need, we must stop choosing
to coerce, force, compel, punish, reward, manipulate, boss, motivate,
criticize, blame, complain, nag, badger, rank, rate, and withdraw. We must replace these destructive behaviors
with choosing to care, listen, support, negotiate, encourage, love, befriend,
trust, accept, welcome, and esteem.
These words define the difference between external control psychology
and choice theory.”
This does not mean that rewards and consequences will never
play a part in raising your child. It
means that it must play a limited role and as soon as is possible, given your
child’s development, it needs to be supplanted with a system of choice that
teaches your child how to make intelligent decisions for himself with your
guidance but not guidance that is so strong that it is merely a disguise for
coercion. “Bobby, you will do your homework or you will be grounded for two
weeks, it’s your choice” is no choice and will in no way help to foster
positive independent decision making in your child. The choice is another form of coercion.
The Pit Fall here is that initially coercion is the easiest
and most effective way to get children to do what we want them to do especially
when they are young. Fear is the strongest motivator. Unfortunately it does not
generalize or help to grow a relationship.
Also as the child gets older and consequences by necessity become more serious you hit a ceiling with nowhere
to go. I mean you can only take so much away and then nothing is left. It is the same problem with corporal
punishment. For it to continue to be
effective the severity, the level of pain inflicted, must be increased and soon
we are in the area of abuse. So although the early results of this approach
look good the long term prospects are disastrous. This
approach, with the knowledge we now have of children, if it came in a package,
would come with a warning from the surgeon general “this approach has proven to
be hazardous to the well being of you and your child.’
We all have basic needs that motivate us and influence our
choices every day and all day and for every day of our lives. These choices can
and have been expressed in a number of different ways but for purposes of
understanding what motivates your child I find that the following work as well
as any. The basic needs of a child., once our physical needs are met (and sometimes before), for food and
shelter are:
-They need
to feel loved and accepted for who and what they are right now not what
you want them to become.
you want them to become.
-They need
to feel that they have something useful even vital to contribute to the
community to which they belong.
-They need
to feel as though they have some control over their lives and that this
control increases as they grow.
-They need
to feel safe both physically and emotionally in the environment
in which they live.
-They need
to have consistent and age appropriate limits placed on their behavior
that helps then gradually learn to deal with
a world that gets bigger for them
every day.
-They need to have realistic expectations placed on them so they learn to be responsible.
-They need to be taught compassion by being treated with compassion.
-They need to have realistic expectations placed on them so they learn to be responsible.
-They need to be taught compassion by being treated with compassion.
You could easily edit this list, it is not a definitive one,
but it does serve to communicate the basic needs that you as a parent need to
provide for you child, beyond the basic needs of food and shelter, if you are
to raise a child who has the ability to make the most out of the world into
which he was born. If these basic needs
are met you will have gone a long way towards creating the foundation needed to
weave a relationship with your child that will have the strength to withstand
the inevitable stresses that will occur between parent and child by giving him
the strength of ego and sense of self worth needed for him to love and accept
himself and in return to genuinely love you.
Wonderful advice! I look forward to more of your posts!
ReplyDeleteThis really is great advice. I am confused about the coercion idea, though. If a child is demonstrating unwanted behavior and not listening to your repeated attempts to ask them to stop - what is appropriate instead of taking something away? I only ask because I go through this situation daily with my four year old. I ask him to do something and he refuses several times, so I tell him that he needs to do it or I will take something away (like his LeapPad). What can I do instead if this is coercion?
ReplyDeleteAmanda
ReplyDeleteA really great question and the answer has a couple parts.
The first is that as with any principle of child rearing there needs to be flexibility. There may well be situations where making your child aware of a consequence you will impose is the most appropriate way to go as long as it isn't your go to technique.
When ever I went shopping with my daughters if they began to whine as a way of persuading me to buy something for them I would promptly leave the store. When doing so I would explain that I was doing this as it was not fair to other shoppers to stay in the store as the whining was so unpleasant to listen to.
I always did this in a matter of fact way and without any implied judgement. I never said that we were leaving as a punishment. They very quickly learned that whining would result in our leaving the store and as a result they would rarely do it.
Second, as a general policy, I would not repeat a request if they had heard it the first time and I had explained why I was making the request. "You have to stop now because we need to eat dinner." Or "you have to get dressed because I have to be somewhere and need to leave now." By repeating the request I would only have been teaching them that they could ignore my request, at least until I had made it several times.
If they failed to respond the first time I would very calmly pick them up and take them to where they needed to be while explaining one more time why I was doing this. Again this was done without judgement and it was never seen as a punishment. What it taught them was that when I asked them to do something I needed it done right then and that there was a good reason for it that they needed to respect. My picking them up, then, became almost a natural response to an ignored request and was less likely to be seen as coercion.
By doing this while they were young they learned to take my requests seriously as they got older.
The thing to remember is that, as with any principle, there needs to be some room for interpretation. If you use a coercive measure, but only infrequently, it will most likely result in no harm as long as it isn't coupled with negative judgement and is the exception rather than the rule.
Third, I like to use natural consequences whenever I can. These are consequences that result in the natural course of events and therefore are not imposed by you. If your child chooses not to listen when you ask him to put his mittens on before he goes out to play in the snow the result will be that his hands get very cold. You didn't cause this but it is very likely that in future he will listen when you advise him to consider the weather when dressing to go out.
The only thing to be aware of is that the natural consequence will not seriously harm your child. If he, for example, wants to do something dangerous, play in traffic, by all means stop him. If, however, by failing to get ready when you ask him he gets left behind, missing something that he wanted to do, well it's just what happens when your late. You can even empathize with him when he is upset and point out again that next time he needs to be ready before it's time to go.
Used correctly natural consequences are a parents best friend.
I hope this helps Amanda and just by virtue of the fact that you are questioning how and what you are doing tells me that you are already way out front when it comes to parenting.
Keep following and letting us know when you have questions. Thanks and happy parenting,
GC